• The Best Greek Burgs in Erie!
  • The Big BLT
  • 922 East Ave, Erie PA
  • Mega Yeero (Gyro)
  • Eat good, feel good!
  • Shredded Steak and Cheese Sandwich on Texas Toast

Greek Sauce Delivery!

Gordon’s Market now selling quart containers of Greek Sauce, delivered straight to your door!
» Order Now

In the News!

Check out our recent feature in the Erie Times News!
» Read the Full Article

What People Are Saying About Us:

    review rating 5  If you never went to New York Lunch, then you never visited Erie. I grew up 2 blocks from the one on East Avenue and I was glad and happy it was right there. Spent many of a dollar there in my lifetime. I know the one on Parade is the more popular one but East Avenue was my place. One of the best foods in town! 5 STAR ESTABLISHMENT!!!

    thumb JF Mulducci
    8/05/2022

    review rating 5  Very nice place . Enjoy the food. And the staff there are wonderful and very quick. And love talking with Nina .

    thumb John and Lori Blose
    8/04/2022

    review rating 5  This is THE definitive "Greek spot" in Erie. Nothing else compares to the experience, quality, and taste - anything else in the area is an imitation. The Cellone's buns are top notch, the sauce is second to none, and the staff knows what they're doing. Do yourself a favor and don't doubt this place based on the rougher neighborhood. You won't regret it

    thumb Pat Benczkowski
    8/04/2022

View More Google Reviews